Methods
Methods and data sources
Every price in the game comes from public U.S. government data. Nothing is estimated or made up.
Source
All prices come from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) Average Price Data, which the BLS collects as part of the Consumer Price Index program. We use the public flat files published at download.bls.gov/pub/time.series/ap/. Bygone Bucks is not affiliated with or endorsed by the BLS, and the BLS has not reviewed this site.
Which series we use
- Only the U.S. city average area. Regional averages are not used.
- Only series with at least 20 consecutive years of annual averages ending in the last complete year.
- Only active series: the latest value must be no more than 3 months older than the newest month in the BLS release. Discontinued series are dropped.
- We picked one series per everyday product and wrote plain-English names for them. Brand and retailer names are never used.
That leaves 39 items today, with records going back as far as 1976. Some familiar products, such as coffee, lettuce and several fruits, are absent because their BLS series have gaps of a year or more, often around 2018–2020 or the October 2025 lapse in federal appropriations, or because they were discontinued.
How prices are computed
- Past years are annual averages: the mean of the monthly prices the BLS published for that year. We compute an annual average only when at least 9 months exist. The BLS's own annual rows are ignored so that all years are treated the same way.
- "Today" is the latest monthly price for each item, labeled with its month. The newest month in the current data is October 2026.
- Prices are not adjusted for inflation. That is the point of the game.
- BLS average prices are national averages across many stores and package sizes, converted to a standard unit such as per pound or per gallon. Your local prices will differ.
How puzzles are chosen
Puzzles are generated in advance by a deterministic program, so everyone gets the same puzzle each day and nobody, including us, picks items by hand. The rules:
- Five different items a day, never two from the same product family (for example, never two kinds of ground beef).
- The same item and year never repeat within 90 days.
- Each day ramps from two easier items to two medium and one hard. Difficulty is estimated from how unusual an item's price change is compared with all items over the same span, plus how familiar the item is.
- Question types alternate between three "then → now" and two "now → then" per day and the reverse the next day.
Data is refreshed monthly. Puzzles already published, and the next two days, are frozen, so a refresh never changes a puzzle you have played.
Limits
BLS average prices are estimates with sampling error, and the BLS sometimes revises recent months. Package sizes, product quality and store mix change over time. The game is for fun and general information, not financial or purchasing advice.